Hi cotters,
I want to share my experience in buying water purifier. I know it can be a headache if you are looking for one and no one seems to know what you are talking about. So let’s share, shall we?
This article is quite long, so please bear with me, ya. (If it’s too long to post, please let me know)
Usually, I always drank from tap water directly, even from public toilet (refilling my water bottle). At home, the taste is quite ok for me. My sister cannot take it, so she always boil it. I could not stand the taste of boiled water. In public toilet, the chlorine taste is quite strong. But Singapore’s water should be safe for drinking, so I did not really care so much drinking from public toilet (or tap water at home) last time. But nowadays I always look for the water dispenser near the toilet to refill my water bottle.
After reading several reviews these past few days and based on my personal experience with tap water, I found that I need to filter my drinking water. But which water filter suits me best? Yes, the Spore drinking water is safe to drink. But the problems lie in the pipes during transportation to our home tap. It can be rusty, contain molds/algaes, etc.
I did some tests few months back. I cover the tap with filter clothes bought from DIY or neighborhood’s shop. After few weeks, the clothes became brown from sedimentation in the tap water. This sedimentation could not be removed by boiling water.
Also, I find this article about boiling water
http://www.urwater.com.au//products/gurgle_tap.asp
In short, boiling kills disease causing organism, but it can cause chlorinated water to release small amount of chloroform gas into the air.
OK, so now into my research of water filter. So many water filters, but which one to suit me? I googled and found this page:
http://www.waterfiltercomparisons.co...comparison.php
But, there’s a catch. In the page, it seems
aquasana holds the best tap water filter. But…. This page was created by them because I found similar page descripting the same comparison. Price wise, need to be careful because only the filters accounts for the price. Not the device itself. I have read through
Aquasana, Brita, Culligan (only short one), eSpring, and Pur. Most offers the same feature of reducing harmful elements (I could not find the exact details of percentage of reduction in respective homepage except for aquasana). eSpring and Pur have extra benefit of reducing bacteria and harmful virus. Then, in Spore there is
OSIM, also claims to reduce 99.99% bacteria. But the device is so small. I am a bit doubtful >_< Also
Diamond is quite popular from what I read from cotters because it can reduce the size of water molecules for ease of water absorption into the body. I did not find about bacteria reduction though. There is also
Hyflux (I did not read much about this),
Gurgle (
http://www.urwater.com.au//products/gurgle_tap.asp) – claims to reduce general bacteria and some viruses) costs S$104 from DIY store (source: my friend :p).
The best that I read from reviews is water distiller. However, not feasible for me because not much space in my apartment plus it is noisy and slow. 5 hours for 4 L of water. Plus it heats the water first (wasting electricity – yeah, I do not want my electricity bill to go up >_<)
I almost bought one of the tap filter, but then, I realize I will probably not like there is something on my tap. Silly me…
So I downgraded – jug water filter or water dispenser. Note: tap filter performs better than jug filter. But I like slower filtration because I am ensured that the harmful materials are filtered out. Here I only list out whether the filter system can filter out bacteria or other microorganism. Other than that, they have similar features to each other (similar does not mean the same

but I can compromise that) I have few choices:
-
Brita Marella XL 3.5 L S$67 (incl 1 filter): no filtering of bacteria (at least I could not find this claim in the website). Cost of filter: 3 for S$36 (maxtra filters) Life time: ~ 150L or 2 months whichever is faster. Has water dispenser for 8L water. But I read reviews that the tap sometimes can leak, also not all water can be dispensed out.
-
Panasonic 2 L S$ 69 (won Women’s weekly award 2009) incl filter. Filter lifetime: 3 months with 4L a day. (quite worth it I think, but it’s out of stock! I also could not find the price of the filter)
http://panasonic.com.sg/web/pid/6560
-
Pur – claims to reduce bacteria with its 2-stage system, though in website, 2 stage does not seem to reduce bacteria
http://www.purwater.com/pur-technology/ I see one in Takashimaya but did not notice the price
-
Novita (our own Spore brand) ~ S$68-80 (I forgot the exact price). Incl filter. Filter life: 35 days 145 L. Each filter costs S$ 45
http://www.novita.com.sg/drink-2210.htm have anti bacterial silver impregnation. Novita also have water dispenser costs S$ 169 and S$ 268
-
Cleansui (Body made in China, filter and design – Japan) ~ S$ 80
-
Gurgle – 1.5 L at AUD 27.5. Filter life 8 weeks or 150 L whichever faster
In the end, I chose
Brita Marella. The water does not have chlorine odor or taste anymore. Yay!
Bookmarks