Best Water proof / smudge proof eye liners

[ksychan]

For smudgeproof eyeliner, K-Palette 24hr Liner and Kiss Me Heroine liquid eyeliner work very well and can be easily removed using Cleansing Express for eyes.

[LadySilver]

The best eyeliners I have tried so far are:

1. Urban Decay 24/7 eye pencil - awesome eyeliners, easy to use and glide, intense color and doesn't smudge at all, long lasting!

2. Dior crayon eye pencil - easy to use and glide, pretty intense color, slightly matt effect, long lasting and doesnt smudge too, if you want a softer look, this is the one!

3. Mac liquid eyeliner in pen form - intense color, easy to use, pointed tips that allows right amount of liquid, doesnt smudge too!

[Kkkalynnnn]

Lancome eyeliner is pretty smudge proof.