Best Water proof / smudge proof eye liners

[fairydust]

MAC Liquidlast and Bourjois Clubbing. If I had to choose between the two, my vote goes to MAC. It's the absolute best thing! I use my Dermalogica Precleanse for removal and it works fine.

[marlenewee]

I just came back from KL and bought the much raved about Kate SuperSharp eyeliner after reading so much about it from various forums. i must say that it is very easy to apply... but unfortunately, the effect is not suited for my eyes. Eyeliner pencil works better for me. So after using it twice, i now wish to sell my Kate SuperSharp eyeliner away at $10. For those who are not aware, Kate products are not available in Singapore. SMS me at 93850222 if interested to take over my Kate eyeliner!

[rocking chick]

MAC Fluidline and MAC Liquidlast

[brownpaperbag]

I like bobbi brown gel liner. It doesn't smudge and it lasts the whole day. I experienced eyeliners that will fade away mid-day or smudge after a while but this one doesn't. It's my HG. As you only need to use a little each time, a small pot lasts forever, I can never finished it.

I am not sure about bobbi brown's gel liner. but i know their ultra fine eyeliner brush is the shiznit!!!! Woots! Ok but I tried Bobbi Brown's pencil before. Smudged like crazy. So now I'm using Kate with BB's ultra fine eyeliner brush. Haha.

[magnugget]

faceshop's gel eyeliner !
the black is really intense, waterproof and smudgeproof !
the other time when i went over to a chalet ( last min ) with my eyeliner on,
i didnt brought any makeup remover and ended up i had the eyeliner on for
2days 1 night :p

[Aud]

I just came back from KL and bought the much raved about Kate SuperSharp eyeliner after reading so much about it from various forums. i must say that it is very easy to apply... but unfortunately, the effect is not suited for my eyes. Eyeliner pencil works better for me. So after using it twice, i now wish to sell my Kate SuperSharp eyeliner away at $10. For those who are not aware, Kate products are not available in Singapore. SMS me at 93850222 if interested to take over my Kate eyeliner!

Don't know about the SuperSharp eyeliner, but Kate products ARE available in Singapore e.g. in BHG.

[redfire]

^ Yepp Kate Supersharp liner is available in Singapore, been getting mine since 2005 Really love this eyeliner, easy application, smudgeproof, waterproof. The only complaint I have is that it's not intense/black enough for me nowadays, even after layering. But, it's really a waterproof/smudgeproof eyeliner and a breeze to take off with makeup remover!

For really really waterproof/smudgeproof, MAC Fluidlast lasts even through swimming and showering. But, it's a pain to remove!

[geeko]

hohoho...

MAC liquidlast..

chop chop 100% guranteed smudgeproof, budgeproof and waterproof

So much so that it's a pain in the neck to remove it that i hardly use it...

[Jadetive]

For pencils, Revlon's Colorstay is really good. And for gels/liquid liners, I'd vote for MAC's fluidlines too.

[Aud]

Agree. Revlon Colorstay pencils are cheap and pretty lasting. They do fade slightly towards the end of the day though.

[sugarette-star]

how about maybelline's liquid liner? is it good?

[dionneee]

my friend recommended revlon's as well.
but i have yet to try.
im still using mac's but not so good for me. tend to smudge after half a day.

[crackerlim]

I need to find one that is really smudgeproof!

[barbiegirl]

I'm looking for a waterproof and smudgeproof pencil liner to line my lower lids. Revlon pencil liner smudges on me. Is MUFE pencil liners smudgeproof enough for lower lids?

[dollshot]

Bobbi Brown's gel liner!